อย่าลืมอ่าน Rolling Stone นะแอบแสบทีเดียว รู้สึกจะไม่ค่อยลงรอยกะมารายห์เอาเสียเลย คำวิจารณจาก Users ให้ 0 ก็มี อย่าคิดไรมาก อ่านเอาขำๆ
จากการวิจารณ์ ได้ 61 /100 จากสถาบันต่างๆ มีดังนี้
All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review
90 Amazon.com
Emancipation works the kind of pure-pop magic that sets us all free.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B0007GAERG/ref=cm_rev_all_1/104-4557705-4052735?v=glance&s=music&vi=reviews
80 Vibe
Mariah gets back to her winning formula with Mimi. [May 2005, p.139]
80 Blender
Sets the gold standard for diva records in 2005. [May 2005, p.118]
80 The Guardian
Despite its grim title with its visions of messy self-absorption, The Emancipation of Mimi is - mostly - cool, focused and urban.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/arts/reviews/story/0,11712,1449385,00.html
75 Entertainment Weekly
Heavy on ballads and midtempo love songs, it always keeps at least one foot (more often both feet) planted firmly in comforting old-school diva soul. [15 Apr 2005, p.76]
70 The New York Times
On "The Emancipation of Mimi," she disciplines herself into coherence, using fewer tricks and sounding more believable. She also finds what lesser singers can take for granted: a certain lightness that eases her constant sense of control. [11 Apr 2005]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/11/arts/music/11choi.html?
70 Billboard
While her voice has lost some of its power through the years, "Mimi" deftly showcases her still-considerable pipes with strong lyrics and slick production.
http://www.billboard.com/bb/reviews/album_article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1000874390
70 Slant Magazine
But whatever the songs lack, they make up for in restraint--brevity keeps you wanting more, which is really Mimi's virtue.
http://www.slantmagazine.com/music/music_review.asp?ID=571
70 PopMatters
Carey does not completely hearken back to her old days, but The Emancipation of Mimi does prove her staying power.
http://popmatters.com/music/reviews/c/careymariah-emancipation.shtml
67 Stylus Magazine
Its easily the strongest album that shes made in this millennium, but suffers from the fact that her vocals have deteriorated.
http://www.stylusmagazine.com/review.php?ID=2923
60 All Music Guide
It might not be as hip as it thinks it is, nor is it as catchy as it should be, but it's smooth and listenable.
http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:m9cyxdjb5olj
50 Dot Music
Charmingly forgettable.
http://uk.launch.yahoo.com/050420/33/1xkmj.html
50 E! Online
A set of predictable, plastic, street-tough R&B jams.
http://www.eonline.com/Reviews/Facts/Music/RevID/0,1107,3438,00.html
50 Rolling Stone
There aren't any great songs among Mimi's club tunes and pop-chart-conscious tracks, and Carey is still suffering from a serious crisis of confidence.
http://www.rollingstone.com/reviews/album/_/id/7208066
50 Los Angeles Times
Her sadly depleted voice is again propped up by multi-tracking, and the occasional dog-deafening shriek hardly proves she's recaptured her early acrobatic power. [10 Apr 2005]
20 New Musical Express
'Mimi' manages the unique trick of being self-indulgent without actually ever sounding much like Mariah. [16 Apr 2005, p.51]
ส่วน คนทั่วไปที่ฟังอัลับ้ม ได้ 7.8/10 จาก 152 คน
มาอ่านดูบางความเห็น
Joe A gave it a 0:
Calling it trash would be an insult to trash.
Mr Bojangles gave it a 1:
This really really sucks. Once again, the music industry(100% corrupt), the retards of the American public(85%) and the grammies (100% old and irrelevant) conspire to give me indigestion and diarhea.
Clayton T gave it a 10:
BEst album of her Career! The voice is indeed back and the writing though alittle juvinile is fun and still consistent. Many artist would do good to take note from her ability to have fun on her records and not take themselves so seriously. She is a lengend indeed and will always be the greatest and hardest working talent in the music industry.
Hairam Y gave it a 10:
Anyone who suks obviously doesnt know good music. yes, maybe she like flopped her last 2 songs, and she may have already has her pinnacle of her career, but this album proves mariah still has what we all want. her song 'we belong together' shows us she still ahs what it takes to go to #1, 'shake it off' tells us why the only song stopping it from reaching #1 was 'we belong together', and it has all the range from songs when ur heart is broken to when u want to get up and dance. also on the release dont forget about us, this slow ballad is more proof y mariah has reached #1 two times in 2005, more than any artist that year. also she is assured to win at least 4 of her 8 grammies. Mariah I know you'll get more than 20 #1's and beat every other artist!!!!
Max Z gave it a 10:
Mariah Carey has proved herself over her 15 years. Although Glitter was a major flop and Charmbracelet destroyed her vocals, this album is Mariah picking herself back up. With 17 #1's she's tied with Elvis Presley and maybe she'll beat Beatles. This album has songs that are a reminder why she has broken so many records. Although I think this album is her pinnacle in this millennium, Mariah always proves us wrong over and over again. Also I'd like to forgive all those people who are too narrow-minded to realize Mariah's success.
http://www.metacritic.com/music/artists/careymariah/emancipationofmimi#critics
แก้ไขเมื่อ 15 ม.ค. 49 17:15:30
แก้ไขเมื่อ 15 ม.ค. 49 16:54:43
+++มาดูคะแนน และคำวิจารณ์ อัลบั้ม มิิมิ ของแต่ละสถาบันกัน+++
