ความคิดเห็นที่ 2
ยอดเยี่ยมมากครับ
และขอเสริมท่านครับ จากกระทู้เดิมที่เสียไป
Question Greetings be to those who are the followers of righteous guidance, [004:082] Do they not consider the Quran (with care)? Had it been from other Than God, they would surely have found therein Much discrepancy.
Very well knowing that Allah challenges in the Quran the Disbeleivers to find Discrepancy,I post this question. Ribs and Backbone? Yusuf Ali: [086:006] He is created from a drop emitted- [086:007] Proceeding from between the backbone and the ribs: Transliteration: [086:006] Khuliqa min ma-in dafiqin [086:007] Yakhruju min bayni alssulbi waalttara-ibi Sher Ali: [086:006] He is created of a gushing fluid, [086:007] Which issues forth from between the loins and the breastbones. Shakir: [086:006] He is created of water pouring forth, [086:007] Coming from between the back and the ribs. Pickthall: [086:006] He is created from a gushing fluid [086:007] That issued from between the loins and ribs. Sale: [086:006] He is created of seed poured forth, [086:007] issuing from the loins, and the breast-bones. Muhammad Al-Hilali & Muhsin Khan: [086:006] He is created from a water gushing forth [086:007] Proceeding from between the back-bone and the ribs, Palmer: [086:006] he is created from water poured forth, [086:007] that comes out from between the loins and the breast bones. Arberry: [086:006] he was created of gushing water [086:007] issuing between the loins and the breast-bones. Khalifa: [086:006] He was created from ejected liquid. [086:007] From between the spine and the viscera. Rodwell: [086:006] He was created of the poured-forth germs, [086:007] Which issue from the loins and breastbones:
In all the available translations of the Quran we see that it is being said that man is created from a drop gushing forth between from between the RIBS AND THE BACKBONE.Well I being a doctor can say that this scientifically incorrect.
The Muslim apologist's explanation regarding how the Testes and the Ovaries develop from Mesonephros (a part near the Kidney) is deceiving and call easily lure the common Man.But a closer look at the above Ayahs reveals quite contrary to what is presented.We see that Allah is talking about the Sperm or Fluid or water coming from between the ribs and the backbone not the organ which produces it.Hippocrates theory once stated the same as mentioned in the Quan that the sperm arised from kidneys. Once again the explanation that the blood supply and lymphatic drainage comes from BETWEEN THE RIBS AND THE BACKBONE, is deceiving.No where is there any mention of such thing in the preceding verses or verses which come afterwards.Also it is mentioned that the water gushing forth comes from this place not its blood supply orotherwise. The explanation of Allah trying to avoid using the word testes is wrong because there is no need to mention ribs or backbone in explaining such an easy thing.Anatomically this explanation fails.If Allah is All knowing he definitely Knows anatomy.
The only last explanation which I can see will save Islam from Doctors and Medical professionals is that the verses have been wrongly interpreted.It could be that the Word Taereb could also imply Hipbone.This would leave us with the interpretation that Man comes out from Between the Backbone and the Hipbone.
Please do deep research on this topic and answer me, Cause the life and faith of About 40 Muslim doctors is in stake. Thanking you in anticipation, Yours Faithfully, DR. IMRAN K CHITALWALA.
จากคุณ :
ดาบจันทร์เสี้ยว
- [
4 ธ.ค. 49 18:31:27
]
|
|
|