ความคิดเห็นที่ 117
คำถามที่คุณ คห 107 ถาม จะมีอยู่ทั้งหมดในการบรรยาย
ถ้าท่านรู้ภาษาอังกฤษ
สำหรับคำถามที่ว่าพระเจ้ามีจริงๆหรือ คำตอบคือ
นี้เป็นส่วนหนึ่งของการบรรยายในหัวข้อ
QURAN AND MODERN SCIENCE
CONFLICT OR CONCILIATION?
จาก
http://www.aswatalislam.net/DisplayFilesP.aspx?TitleID=50027&TitleName=Zakir_Naik
(Q) As-Salam Alaikum Zakir bhai - My name is Shakir, and I am a Mechanical Engineer student. I would like to ask you a question, that how can you prove to an atheist scientifically the existence of God? .
(Dr.Zakir). The brother has posed a question, how can you scientifically prove the existence of God Almighty, the existence of Allah (SWT) to especially to an Atheist, who does not believe in God. The first thing I will do is that , I will congratulate that Atheist. I will congratulate him - You know why? If you look around us - he is a Hindu because father is a Hindu - He is a Christian because father is a Christian - Some Muslims are Muslims because their fathers are Muslim. This person, though he may be coming from a religious background, he does not believe in the false god which his parents attribute to - so he does not believe in God. I am congratulating him because he has accepted the first word of the Shahada, the first part of the Islamic creed La Ilaha - there is no god. Now my job is to prove Illallah, but Allah - which I shall do Inshaallah. To the other people, I have to first to remove the wrong concept of god and then prove the right concept of the Allah (SWT). Here half my job is done. He has already said La Ilaha - There is no god. Now I have to prove Illallah, but Allah - which I shall do Inshaallah. You ask this Atheist, that suppose there is an object
an unidentified
may be a flying object which no one in the world has seen - No human being in the world knows about this object. If it is brought in front of you, and if you ask that who will be the first person who will be able to tell you the mechanism of this unidentified object, you have to ask him the question. Who is the first person , who will be able to tell you the mechanism of this new object which no one in the world has seen? After thinking for a while, he will give the answer the person who will be able to tell you the mechanism
the first person, is the Creator of that object. Some may say Manufacturer, some may say Producer. Whatever they say, dont grapple with the words
accept it - It will be somewhat similar. Either Creator, or Producer, or Manufacturer - but remember what he has told you - Keep it in your mind. Then ask him the next question - How did the Universe come to existence - How was it formed? He will tell you by the Big Bang Theory. Tell him the Quran mentions in Surah Anbiya, Ch. 21, V. No. 30, about the Big Bang Theory. Who could have mentioned this in the Quran 1400 years ago? - He will tell you
May be it is a fluke. Dont argue with him - Next part of the question. We did not know the light of the Moon is reflected light - We came to know recently - You ask him. He will tell you
Yes, yes the light of the Moon is reflected light it is not its own light. When we discovered ? He will tell you
Recently, yesterday, fifty years back, hundred years back, yesterday in science. You tell him, the Quran mentioned that the light of the moon is reflected light, fourteen hundred years ago. Who could have mentioned that ? May be somebody had a wild guess. Do not argue with him
. Continue - We thought the sun was stationary. You ask him - Is it stationary ? He will say
No it is rotating and revolving. When did you learn this? He will tell you
Yesterday
fifty years back
twenty years back. Quran mentioned this fourteen hundred years ago. He will hesitate, but may say May be, some intelligent person wrote it. Dont argue with it
Continue. How was the universe initially - What is celestial matter ? He will tell you it was Smoke. How did you come to know ? We have got proof, we have got evidence. You tell him
Quran mentioned this fourteen hundred years ago. Who could have mentioned that? - He will hesitate. Dont wait for a response
Continue - Keep on posing question after question. All that I have given in the lecture - Keep on posing one question after the other. That, water cycle, how did you come to know about it? Quran mentioned it fourteen hundred years ago. About every living thing made from water - Who could have mentioned that ? Quran speaks about Botany - the male and female - Who could have mentioned that ? Pose one after the other and ask the question Who could have written that ? Then you tell him there is a theory known as Theory of Probability.That if you have two choice, out of which one is right - the chances that you will make the correct choice just at random, is one in two. For example, if I toss a coin it can be either heads or tails - The chances I will be right, will be one in two. If I toss it twice, the chances I will be right both the times, will be 1/2 multiplied by 1/2 that is 1/4. Twenty five percent chance. If I toss it thrice, chances I will be right all three times, 1/2 multiplied by 1/2 multiplied by 1/2, it is 1/8. 12 and 1/2 %. A dice has got six sides. If I throw a dice, the chances that at random I will be correct is 1/6. If I through it twice, the chances that both the times I will be right, will be 1/6 x 1/6 which is 1/36. This is called as Theory of Probability. If I throw the dice twice, and then toss a coin, all three being right will be 1/6 multiplied by 1/6 multiplied by 1/2 is 1/72. So you ask him - the chances may be if you ask - what is the shape of the earth? There are various shapes. Some may say if is flat, some may say its triangular, some may say it is hexagonal, some may say pentagonal, some may say heptagonal, some may say square. Say there can be ten shapes. Some may say it is round, it is spherical - the chances that if any one makes a wild guess, it being correct, is 1/10. The light of the Moon - it can either be its own light, or it can be reflected light. The chances that you make a wild guess and it being correct will be one upon two. The chances that both shape of the earth and light of the moon being reflected light- both being correct, if you make a wild guess - it will be 1/10 multiplied by 1/2, it is 1/20. What can the living creatures be made of ? Some may say Sand, some may say Stone, some may say Aluminum, some may say Gold - say a thousand materials you can name. Some may say Water, some may say Silver, a thousand materials. The chances that you make a wild guess, and one of them being right according to mathematics, is one upon a thousand. The chances that all three being correct - the earth is spherical, light of the moon is reflected light, and every living creature created from water
is correct, will be 1/10 multiplied by 1/2 multiplied by 1/1000. Answer comes to 1/20,000 or 0.005 percent. Quran speaks about scientific
science more than a thousand verses. In three verses, the chances comes to .05 percent. If you apply probability theory to all these being at random, chance it will come to zero
negligible. And in Maths - anything one in ten raise to fifty, it is equal to zero. So you ask your Atheist friend
Who could have written this? The only answer he can give you is, his first answer the Creator, the Manufacturer. The person who has produced it That is the only answer. There is no other answer. What Science is saying today is
They are not eliminating God
They are eliminating models of god. La Ilaha IllAllah. They are not eliminating god but models of god. I hope that answers the question.
จากคุณ :
pong
- [
2 พ.ย. 47 12:51:50
A:61.90.95.205 X: TicketID:077531
]
|
|
|
... เข้ามาดู
